'City Paper' interview: Mayor talks taxes, charter schools, Med Mart and more

Sunday, May 6, 2012 at 10:52pm
507DeanPhoto.jpg

Mayor Karl Dean (Michael W. Bunch/SouthComm)

 

Karl Dean knows he has some sales work to do.

Nashville, like many cash-strapped cities across the country, has put off any number of decisions, plans and projects during the recession. After deferring the city’s debt obligations for two years, dipping into the “rainy day” fund and holding the line on the budget, Dean has proposed a 53-cent hike to the city’s $4.13 tax rate — an overall 12.83 percent bump, just pennies under the amount that would trigger a referendum, to raise $100 million in new revenue.

But any tax increase will not be easy to pass.

At a meeting with City Paper editors, Dean pled his case, painting a fairly dark picture of what kinds of cuts would be needed without a tax increase.

“We’re at a point now, if we cut further — and we are actually eliminating about $3 million from operating budgets — to the level you would need to cut and not have a tax increase, you would be talking about cuts that would definitely go into muscle,” he said. “We’d have to lay off 200 police officers, 200 firefighters, 200 teachers, close all the branch libraries, close all of the community centers. And you still wouldn’t be there.

“Either you go backwards, where you set the city back in terms of quality of life as an appealable place to live, or do you go forward. I’m not willing to turn back on public safety. I’m not willing to turn back on education. I do believe that we’ve made real progress in both of those areas.”

As he began the work of selling the tax, we talked with Dean and finance director Rich Riebeling about the budget and a range of issues affecting Nashville right now.

 

Total, there’s about a $3 million reduction in department budgets along with the tax increase. How much thought did you give to raising the tax 3 cents more [to 56 cents] and go all the way to the limit before it would have triggered a referendum?

Dean: One of my goals was, and this is the guiding principle of my first term because of the recession, I thought it would be totally inappropriate to raise taxes in the middle of the worst recession since the Great Depression. It would have been just taking money away from the public and putting it in government’s hands when the public is hurting. We’re still not fully in a position where I would say the economy is as strong as we’d like it to be. Unemployment here is 6.6 percent; we’re well below where we were in 2008. We’re a point-and-a-half below the national average. I wanted to keep it as low as I could.

 

Every four years property is reappraised, and that will happen again next year. Do you factor in how that might change what people might be paying then (i.e. less because of a drop in the real estate market) and calculate a property tax rise based on that?

Dean: As best as you can, because it’s all guesswork now as to what will happen next year. I will say that the situation next year is probably looking different than at any point in Metro’s history. Generally you could bank on housing prices going up. Nashville has been much more stable than most major cities, but I can’t say with absolute certainty that Nashville housing prices are going to go up, and I can’t say that they will go up to a degree that it will give us a lot of room or comfort [in the budget]. We thought about that, but it wasn’t a major consideration.

 

Only five of the 40 council members have ever voted on a tax rate change.

Dean: It’s like Garrett, Steine ... the ones that have come back from other lives.

 

I think you started making the case to the council yesterday. How do you continue to make that?

Dean: I think it really comes down to what I said. It’s kind of a crossroads decision. And to me the choice is just so stark. When you’re talking about cutting $100 million out of the budget, there’s just no easy way to do that. I mean, if you do it, you will literally be ... People say you’re using scare tactics when you talk about cutting teachers and police, but we’ve cut everything else. Since I’ve been mayor, we’ve cut 59.2 million out of the Metro budget. There are over 660 fewer Metro employees than when I started.

I’m sure there are things you can go in and find that have to go, but there ain’t $100 million. And there ain’t $20 million. And there ain’t $10 million. And so, it’s really a decision about how you see the city. It’s a decision about whether you just refuse to raise taxes because of some sort of anti-tax position in any situation, or whether you bet on the future of the city. I think Nashville, when you’ve got a choice of going back or betting on the future, you always bet on the future. And so, the choice was easy for me, and I think it’s pretty clear to most. I don’t think there’s any easy answers, saying, “Just don’t do it because we don’t want to raise taxes.” The other thing people have to understand is that local government is different. It’s not like the federal government in the sense that we can’t print money. We can’t operate at a deficit. Through the reappraisal process for our most basic foundation of financial support. And we have to periodically make those decisions. And cities grow. And the best example I give is what I said about schools — and this is a positive thing — but enrollment in our public schools goes up every year now. And you can’t just say, “We’re gonna get by with the teachers we’ve got.” You can’t.

 

Let’s talk about two specific capital items. You talked about the purchase of land to expand Julia Green Elementary. Is that just for the land or is there money budgeted for expansion?

Dean:The plan is to put money in for land acquisition. I’ve got something to say about it, but these are school recommendations about where their needs are. For instance, with the high schools, they rank them, and they have a number they can put for each school and what the priority is. Stratford (which would get a $20 million makeover) was No. 1.

 

Two years ago we budgeted maybe $10 million for that East Nashville Highland Heights building, which didn’t get funded. Now it will be $16 million. Is that going to be in the capital plan?

Riebeling: Probably so. There’s a couple of projects like that. Highland Heights was originally going to be something they restored and [they would] renovate the original building, and it was determined that wasn’t a feasible figure. We’re gonna preserve part of the building and build new around it, so the cost has gotten higher than what the budget originally was. It was originally kind of a [guess], but now they’ve got detailed plans, they can firm the number up. Highland Heights is more than just a school. If you talk to the neighbors there and the councilman, that’s seen as kind of a historic and central point for the community. That area’s going through a real interesting revitalization right now. You’ve got restaurants over there right now. You’ve got a mix of everything. I think for that community — and [charter operator] KIPP will lease the building — it’s seen as not just a school but as a statement for the community for them to meet and play. There will be open-space areas. It’s more than just a school; it’s a central point for the area.

Dean: And the arrangement is — and this gets lost in all these discussions — KIPP is a public school. It is paid for by public dollars, and there are public students attending that school. Some people like to shade that, but that’s the facts. The deal was, and this is no criticism of anybody there now and I don’t know how it happened, this was a situation like Turner School, where you had this building where the schools abandoned it, essentially, and left it on their rolls, and they don’t do anything with it. And then when KIPP Academy comes to Nashville and becomes a public charter school, they put them there. And two-thirds of the building is uninhabitable. When I first saw it, it bothered me to see what I saw. We’re left then with this school that’s two-thirds unusable, a public school that is succeeding beyond expectations, a fixture that is important to that neighborhood, and you’ve got to make a decision about what you’re going to do. The schools did not have an interest in upgrading a thing for a public charter school, which is one of their schools. I did. I think that’s the right decision.

 

The average person hears about a tax increase and says, “We’re building this giant Music City Center” and doesn’t realize that they’re different pools of money. Is that a challenge to get across to people that this $585 million project isn’t tied to the increase?

Dean: Look, I’ve been preaching that for 4 1/2 years. The first question I got after my [State of Metro] speech was, “How are you going to explain the convention center?” Kind of my answer is that a lot of the obligation is on the media. I mean, the fact is that there is not one bit of property tax that has gone into the construction of that building. Not one cent. I guess, other than the time I spend talking about it and working on it, whatever goes to my salary.

But the financing model that we did — that builds the thing using the hotel/motel tax, and then the tourist zone will kick in at its completion — has worked beyond our expectations. We didn’t get credit for it at the time, but we were using very conservative estimates. We’re $11 million exceeding our revenue collections right now, and the center hasn’t even opened. As we’re speaking, the Omni is being built by Omni. Another hotel is being built on West End, and there will be another hotel built downtown in the next year or two. That’s just the facts. I’ll keep repeating them. But that has nothing to do with property tax. And if somebody says it in a public forum, you oughta call them on it.

 

One of the things when Music City Center was pitched was that there would be some sort of redevelopment of the current convention center, and the Medical Mart project was put forward. Music City Center is a big hunk of our skyline now, and there’s nothing done with Med Mart. How much longer before we see real progress on it?

Dean: A couple of things ... Med Mart is basically where it’s been in the sense that they have to sign enough leases to make it a financially doable deal for them. The city has no agreements with them. No anything. So we don’t have to do the Med Mart. I can tell you that there is a lot of interest in that property from a lot of different businesses. It’s some of the most valuable property in the city, and of all the things that keep me awake at night, worrying about if we’re going to be able to successfully develop that corner is not one of them. I can tell you that another consideration that needs to be discussed is that we need it for a convention center for a while. We cannot legally say we’re not going to use it as a convention center because we’ve got an agreement with the Renaissance Hotel [adjoining the current center] that we’re going to operate a convention center for some time. For us to do anything is going to involve resolving that issue. And we’ve got conventions booked beyond the opening of the new convention center.

I don’t feel the pressure. I feel that because the economy has turned, and Nashville’s kind of a hot city right now, we’re getting lots of inquiries and there’s lots of possibilities, and for us it’s just making sure what the right thing is.

 

It sounds like you’re open to other things besides just the Med Mart.

Dean: The bottom line is we’re going to do the best thing for the city of Nashville, whatever road we go down. I believe that the Med Mart folks have a good concept, but at some point you have to execute. I don’t feel cornered in. I really don’t.

 

When is the point that they have to execute?

Dean: It’s pretty flexible. What I mean is, we don’t have an agreement. I don’t have to do anything other than find the deal that makes the most sense. There are a lot of people that might be interested if we do A, B or C to help them get interested, and we might not want to do those things. And the Med Mart is a great idea. It would be a transformative thing for downtown if it happened. And there are other things that would be appealing, too. We’ve agreed to give them time, and we’ll just see how it goes. But like I said, we have an obligation to run a convention center for some time, and we can’t go off and start tearing down that building this year. It would be legally wrong, and we’ve got parties coming in for conventions.

 

On the back side of the arena, there’s been talk of a small entertainment district there.

Dean: I think the Predators would acknowledge, and I certainly think, that’s going to be transformed. The back of the Bridgestone ... I never think of it so much as the back entrance as “where you go to smoke.” That clearly is now at the key tourist intersection of the city, because you’ve got the convention center, the hall of fame, the Hilton and [the arena]. And, in time you’ll see that being activated in some way with retail, restaurants and stuff like that. That whole wall going up Fifth Avenue will be activated in time. There’s no real immediate plans to do that, but that’s what will happen. Fifth Avenue itself as part of the convention center project will be transformed. That will be a wholly different street a year from now. And then there’s also work being done with the avenue of the arts. Things will happen at Bridgestone, but there’s nothing on the drawing board right now or no plans.

 

You mentioned fielding calls from other cities and people checking out Nashville and how hot it is. When you’re fielding those calls, do you ever hear, “Gee, we’d love to come down, all this social agenda legislation is worrying us.” Do they ever say, “What the hell is going on with the legislature in Tennessee?”

Dean: I won’t mention names, I’m not really at liberty to mention it, but there have been companies who have actually come here who have heard about some of the social legislation and expressed concern. My position has always been, particularly in the area of nondiscrimination, that that absolutely shoots us in the foot. Particularly if you’re a cultural city and an artistic city and a university city. I think Nashville stands on its own. I think people look at Nashville and know that it’s different. Cities have to be friendly, which we are. Cities have to be inclusive, which I think we are, and we try to get more and more inclusive. That’s the way government in cities should operate. But I have heard it. The business [in question] came.

 

Tennessee has been hemorrhaging jobs in the film industry to neighboring states that have incentive plans. There are anecdotal stories of Nashville residents packing up and moving to Georgia and Louisiana where the movie work is. Since the state is not going to provide any
of these incentives, is there anything Nashville will do to lure this work?

Dean: One of the things that this music council that we’ve formed has looked at is how we can do more work with doing scores for film. And I think that’s a real possibility. I’d love to see more film here. We just had a company that was filming a pilot here that I guess we’ll find out this coming month if it’s been picked up by one of the networks. It’s called Nashville. There is film work done here. And obviously Nicole Kidman has done some things. The film festival has grown here and FilmCom has grown here.

But if you look at incentives, I guess Louisiana would be the most aggressive one and probably Michigan and the Detroit area, they’re giving cash. It’s pretty expensive. And it’s a tough competition to enter. I would like to see it more here, and part of what we can do here is work to strengthen the music industry, which I think draws some creative people here. And it draws people who are interested in film here. The universities help, too. As a city, we’d be hard-pressed to compete with Louisiana, Michigan and New Mexico with what they do writing checks. I don’t think as a city we can do it.

 

Some of the items in the legislature that were sponsored by the Nashville Area Chamber of Commerce would have essentially gutted some of the city’s zoning abilities. Before the city gives the chamber a $300,000 subsidy in the next budget, have you gotten assurances from them that they won’t put those forward again next year?

Dean: I think they would view that [amount] as payment for services rendered. I think I made my displeasure with the chamber’s position pretty well-known. We’ve had some pretty frank discussions about that, and I’ve been assured that I or a representative from my office could be present to talk whenever there’s any sort of legislation that they’re taking a position on that affects Nashville. I don’t think they deliberately set out to ... I think it somehow fell into a crack, and then it kept going, and then it got a momentum of its own. And it was really problematic. It would have been devastating to local governments all over. The opposition to it was total from every major city in Tennessee and the Middle Tennessee Mayors Caucus. We did a very strong letter saying, “Stop.” I think the chamber’s aware that if we’re going to be partners, we’ve got to be on the same page on a lot of these things. Or at least we’ve got to have a discussion before they go off and do it.

I will say that I support the chamber getting the $300,000. It’s in the budget. It really is to pay for the work Janet Miller and the economic development folks do in bringing us prospects and to give the message of Nashville. They do a good job at it. Part of the reason I was as outspoken as I was about this is that my track record with the chamber has been … that I think, in general, they have been fairly progressive. I don’t agree with them on everything, and there’s certain things I’ve done that they don’t agree with, but I think there are very few chambers of commerce that make their No. 1 priority public education. They haven’t just talked it, they put money into it. They’ve put work into it. They’ve rallied other sources of money in the private sector to help. They’ve been a good ally in all that. I think they’ve been very thoughtful about issues around transportation, too. Their vision of Nashville, I thought, has been far different from the vision that was articulated by the bills that were filed. And it’s not just big cities, it would have been small towns that would have been adversely affected.

 

Along those lines, there has been some concern from parents that the academy programs in public schools are little more than glorified vocational training. Is the ultimate goal of the public school system to create an enticing workforce?

Dean: No. I mean, I don’t have the list of all the different academies. They cover all different subject matters. The last one I visited was I was at the ribbon-cutting for an academy at McGavock [High School] that Country Music Television was a real big sponsor of that teaches advanced TV skills. There’s a great academy at Pearl-Cohn that basically does a news station. They’ve gotten great contributions for it. They still teach the traditional subjects. You still have the traditional college courses. I think it’s important to have IB [international baccalaureate] programs. It’s important to offer those choices to the parents. You clearly still have the magnet schools, too. I think the goal of Metro Schools is for all kids to go to college. Now, that’s not possible, but the goal is not to channel them off into some kind of vocational training. I would reject that. I think that one of the things we do have now is this open enrollment, where you can go to any school you want to. I’m a great believer in a general education, and that’s what I would want if I was a young person. They’re making the choices. We got a grant from the National League of Cities to work on alternative high schools. We created two recently, and we’ve got a new one coming this year that gives kids who aren’t going to succeed in a traditional high school — they’re going to be dropouts — to give them another type of school to go to so they can get through school. You’ve gotta have all different types of schools, because one size doesn’t fit all.

 

I’m sure you saw the state bill that would allow the state to have an entity that would oversee the state fair.

Dean: I think the issue is, and what we’re agreeable to and what the [Metro] council did, is to have this planning done that we’re in the process of doing. And I think that should occur. My point is that the state fair is great, but you’ve gotta have a way to pay for it. This is the first year where we’re at where we thought we’d be. At some point, we’ve gone through all of the reserves. Over the last 10 to 15 years, we’ve spent every bit of the reserves. It’s all gone. So now there’s a supplement in the budget this year. We’ve fully funded what the fair board wants. I’m not hostile to the fair. But the reserves are gone, and the money that will now supplement that will come from the general fund. One of the issues is that if there’s going to be a true state fair, maybe there should be some help to pay for it to turn it into a true state fair and not have something that’s not a state fair. But that bill is totally separate from me. I’ve kept totally separate from that.

 

The governor just vetoed the Vanderbilt “all-comers” bill.

Dean: Good

 

Your thoughts?

Dean: I thought that Gov. Haslam, the opinion he expressed I share with him. I couldn’t express it any better than him. The legislature shouldn’t be telling Vanderbilt what to do. Vanderbilt can figure out if what they did was right. It’s a private institution. I think he was correct to veto it.

 

We hear rumors about you and higher office ...

Dean: I think I’ve got a great job and I’ve got 3 1/2 years to go. There are a lot of things I want to get done, and it will come to an end, and I’ll miss it terribly.

 

Are you ruling out a statewide run for anything?

Dean: I really am not thinking about it. I’m so busy with what I’m doing. There’s all sort of life decisions that have to be made about your age and family. I’m just fixated on getting this job done.

 

There’s a number of charter school operators who have expressed an interest in Nashville. Some critics have said this might lead to a different type of segregation for Nashville. What types of assurances are there that a charter program is not going to undo some of the things that have been done over the past 40 years?

Dean: I think first of all, any charter school, because it’s public, has got to welcome and encourage diversity. It’s got to be a school that makes an effort to attract all types of students. So far, the history charter schools in Nashville is that charter schools have gone into areas where there’s the most need for a change in educational philosophy. The charter advocates I’ve talked to, for instance, like Geoffrey Canada — he did the Harlem Project — he’s a huge believer in charter schools. He came to Nashville before they reformed the laws, and I said, “We need to get you to the state legislature.” I said, “Hear from this guy, because he knows more about charter schools than anybody I’ve met.” He went and talked to people. The other source I would really say really got me in favor of them was Arne Duncan, the secretary of education in the Obama administration. They made it clear that they were not going to aid school districts and states that didn’t reform their charter schools and offer choice to all families.

I mean, the problem is that if you don’t do charter schools, most parents don’t get any choices. It’s just those that can afford to do something different. I think every parent ought to have some choices. I would be always mindful that we would slip, even unintentionally, into some kind of segregation. Because that’s the furthest thing that anybody wants. But I think charter schools have a role to play. They’re not the panacea for traditional schools. You need both. There are very compelling arguments that some of the work that’s being done in some of the most difficult places in the United States now are being done by charters. But charter schools fail, too. What we have to do, if a charter school is failing, is to not be afraid to end it. You can’t do it.

 

The Dean administration is going to be filing legislation regarding the county court clerk’s office regarding tax collection. This comes in light of the investigation into John Arriola and the whole wedding fees controversy. Should Arriola keep his job?

Dean: No. 1, you do have the work that [Attorney General Torry] Johnson is doing, and it would be inappropriate for me as the mayor to comment on it. I have great confidence in Torry to do whatever the right thing is. He’ll do it. In terms of this particular ordinance, the concern was that as a city, we have a fiduciary responsibility to collect all the taxes due us. Rich can talk about the situation with the hotel/motel tax he was collecting.

Riebeling: There’s just some dysfunctionality going on in the office right now, and we weren’t getting the money turned over on a timely basis. The code requires it to be done on a daily basis, and, you know, there’s some leeway there, but it was several weeks at a time. And April 1, there was a bond payment due for convention center bonds. And we couldn’t get the money transferred and posted into the Metro accounts. We weren’t gonna default on the bonds. We were going to make sure the payments were made. But no one seemed to understand the urgency of the matter. We have a duty to collect this tax. And then there was the issue on this liquor tax, and clearly no notices had gone out for a couple of years in terms of, “Are you paying or not?” and the response was, “Well, if you give me more money for postage, maybe I could send out the notice.” Without getting into the politics of it, on the pure business side of it, that’s not the way to run it. What happened was in 1996, Bill Covington was the county clerk, and he went to the legislature and got them to pass something that gave the council the authority to move it from finance to the county clerk. Now it’s simply a matter of getting the council to go back and repeal that and move it back to finance.

As the mayor said, we have a responsibility to make sure we’re collecting taxes, because if you’re paying your liquor tax and the guy down the street isn’t, that isn’t fair. First of all, we’re losing the money, which we need, but secondly, it’s not fair. It’s been in two different audit reports that there needs to be a system of compliance and monitoring to make sure people are paying their tax or fees. No system was put in place. Also, my staff starts worrying that we’re going to have to audit all these people. It takes a big staff to do that. So I told them to go meet with the internal auditor and in a 20-minute meeting figured out how the auditor, who’s independent, will start a monitoring procedure for the largest payers. It’s just a simple process like that that hadn’t been done in 6 to 8 years, and in one 20-minute meeting they worked an arrangement out. That’s $40 million that goes through there.

32 Comments on this post:

By: kamaliman87 on 5/6/12 at 11:51

I can't believe it would be an option to cut in education. I don't care what you say, I think your barking up the tree with that. Police, yeah take it away and see whos there to protect and serve, you take advantage of those guys too, no cost of living raises, they risk their lives everyday, and do all your "gopher work," they direct all your traffic needs, whenever really they shouldn't be tied up to doing that, it should be appointed to a crossing guard type job of some sort. What about this convention center? We hardly ever used the one we had, and Gaylord has their own facilities, why couldn't we partner with them to get discounted city functions and still promote them as a great facilitator with proof for other people to bring business opportunities and functions to Nashville, it is closer to the airport. So I guess since we can't afford cuts, we have no other choice but to pay up. I hope everyone who voted for him sees the short term gains, but long term cost.

By: Ask01 on 5/7/12 at 4:43

Curious isn't it?

The first items on the chopping block are "hot button" issues dealing with the public welfare such as police, firefighters and teachers.

I suggest Mayor Dean consider laying off upper tier city managers or cutting their salaries.

Maybe he and his sidekick could step down also.

There was money to risk for the MCC and now we need a tax increase? We citizens experienced the same type subterfuge under then Mayor Bredesen who, after securing his football team and stadium, suddenly realized the deplorable condition of Nashville's schools and asked for a tax increase.

Maybe, just maybe, our illustrious mayor should not have given away so many tax breaks to lure businesses here in exchange for as yet unrealized, but anticipated future jobs. (Probably part time, seasonal, minimum wage employment which will likely benefit only the business owner by saving on wages.)

OK Nashville, like the old auto commercial, "you asked for it, you got it."

I may not have much, but at least I can proudly exclaim I voted against Mayor Karl Dean.

By: Jughead on 5/7/12 at 8:09

Karl Dean was a huge mistake. I voted for the tax-n-spendtard, and I feel foolish. Sneaky,sneaky,sneaky...and unwilling to address the real solution:cutting spending.
Creep, and a liar.

By: spooky24 on 5/7/12 at 8:10

Regardless Mayor Bredesen would have never been stupid enough to refinanced the cities debt in a deal that no one knows the slightest thing about except that the debt is coming due. To continuously lie about it by saying the debt service would only be 11cents of the the 48 when actually it's 41cents of the entire increase Some bank must have loved that deal..

By: MusicCity615 on 5/7/12 at 8:42

Guys, read the article. Karl Dean has cut $60 million in metro spending under his term. not 1 cent of property tax money has gone to the music city center, no matter what JeffF says.

We have a lot to be thankful for here in Nashville.

By: MusicCity615 on 5/7/12 at 8:43

I don't like my taxes being raised, but I also know that tough decisions have to be made.

By: jvh2b on 5/7/12 at 8:52

Thank you MusicCity615

Apparently we need a LOT more money in schools, considering we have people on here complaining about an issue DIRECTLY addressed in the article.

LEARN HOW TO READ BEFORE YOU OPEN YOUR TRAP PEOPLE! You may actually then come off as having a well formed opinion.

Jeez.

By: BigPapa on 5/7/12 at 8:52

Im glad others have picked up on the tactic that when it comes time to raise taxes the first things considered is fire, police, and schools, but when it comes time to spend the first things are Pro sports, tourist attractions, etc..

It's like if you were laid off and you decided to cut back by not paying your mortgage, your electric bill, or buy groceries, but still bought cigarettes and beer, took a nice vacation here or there.

By: JeffF on 5/7/12 at 9:49

These are the some of items that were moved from the hotel/motel taxes to the general fund to make room for the MCC's debt service:

-Adventure Science Center
-Nashville Predators stimpend
-Bridgestone Arena stipend
-Special Events funds (primarily CMT Festival, but also other events)
-Annual contribution to the "no taxpayer funds" symphony hall
-The existing convention center sales and operations expenses

all these items were supposedly being paid for by others and are now being paid for by us. Throw in the eventual shifts of Metro fee revenues and the need to have those made up by general fund revenues in order to keep the government (the one we use) running. Removing millions of dollars of tax paying properties from the tax rolls did not help either, but the amount of taxes lost is minute compared to the millions given to tourism/hospitality projects. Way more than 1 cent. Try millions.

Only a complete doofus would say the MCC is costing us nothing. Only a poorly trained party planner and his "I rent AV equipment" nerd lackeys would think that millions of dollars is nothing.

This is the industry that Nashville has decided to support as it's "champion":
http://travel.usatoday.com/hotels/post/2012/04/seattle-report-hotels-dont-pay-workers-a-living-wage/678414/1

And these are the companies that thought we suck and chose to locate real jobs to Williamson County during the same period:
Nissan
Mars
Jackson National
Clarcor

Give the populace low paying, government dependent jobs and blame their subsequent poverty on others so they will vote Democrat. It is the Detroit system.

By: BigPapa on 5/7/12 at 10:09

Yes, I honestly think that Nashville leadership would sell their soul for a few more waiter/waitress jobs. They must really drool at the possibility of hotel housecleaning careers.

By: Jughead on 5/7/12 at 10:13

The schools NEVER stop asking for money. Yet, they become worse every year. They are black holes, and Dean knows he can plead "it's for the children" and liberal nimrods will embrace it.

It is not for the children. It is for MNPS employees who are demoralized, incompetent, and don't care.

No property tax increase. CUT SPENDING!!!

By: Jughead on 5/7/12 at 10:15

Nashville is heading the same direction as Greece and the rust belt. Tax,tax,tax...then business and people relocate to less restrictive municipalities.

I do not want to be like Cleveland, Detroit, Cincinnati, or any other dysfunctional city with a welfare state.

By: MusicCity615 on 5/7/12 at 11:28

JeffF that was a horrible argument. I actually feel better about the MCC after your post.

and please, get real, or realistic. Nissan, Mars, etc. would never have moved to Williamson County if it weren't for all the amneties that are currently in Davidson County...

I bet you are pretty upset Asurion decided to add hundreds of jobs not only in Davison County, but also to downtown. Please let me know if these jobs qualify as "real jobs" as you like to say Davidson County does not have.

By: producer2 on 5/7/12 at 1:14

JeffF
Bad argument. the payments to those entities you listed have only been happening for a very short time. Why you ask? Because the money became available AFTER the current Convention Center paid off its debt obligations in the very same manner as the MCC. WITHOUT USING A DIME OF PROPERTY TAX MONEY. So the Purcell administration saw a way to get some of their pet projects done but funneling money from the general fund that had been paying for these things for a long time and using the hotel/motel fund instead. Not a good way to keep promoting a very large industry for your City...

By: JeffF on 5/7/12 at 2:28

So it is okay to put them on the general fund because years ago they were on the general fund?

As for the "large industry" (number 11 in terms of employment, number 15 for income) please see the news story about government benefits being used to prop up hospitality profits. The same thing Walmart was accused of doing by its haters but this time actually true.

Hospitality is the slum lord of the modern economy. It is absurd that our government will fund slum development over something that actually does have a positive impact on the community. Everyone hates the PSC, but it probably has 5 times more positive economic impact than the downtown hospitality industry does. And no one had to spend a dime of other people's money to get that.

Direct or Indirect, it is still PROPERTY TAX MONEY. Laundering the money via other line items does not turn it into anything other than PROPERTY TAX MONEY.

If meeting planners ever paid property taxes on their businesses they would have a great argument. Hard to pay property taxes when your facilities were built and owned by the government. I'm sure there is a wonderful multiplier the consultants trot out just special (for every client) that will turn zero into billions of dollars and 30,000 new jobs.

By: JeffF on 5/7/12 at 2:31

The convention center did use tax money. Their employees were and are on Metro health and retirement. Those are are not covered by the center because of its 20 straight years of being a loss leader for the hotels. The hotels do not pay benefits or good wages to their own employees, they sure are not going to pay them for the convention center.

By: JeffF on 5/7/12 at 2:37

And once again, real slow, the convention center did not pay off its own debts (see he decades of operating losses), their debt was paid for with taxes collected by Metro and the State and sent to the bond holders. Any check the convention center ever wrote with cash from operations would bounce all the way down Broadway and across the river.

The world would be much different if every business could get the government to tax non-customers and send that to them to payoff their debts. That is a privilege enjoyed only by hospitality, sports, and companies named General Motors.

In accounting we call a business that is incapable of paying it's own debts with its own revenues "insolvent" or "bankrupt". In Nashville, we call it an "investment in the Music City brand".

By: producer2 on 5/7/12 at 2:54

take your meds your gonna have a heart attack. your rambling again...

By: Jughead on 5/7/12 at 3:12

I have a better idea for Dean and the liberals "serving" on Metro Council: REDUCE SPENDING!

By: JeffF on 5/7/12 at 3:15

"and please, get real, or realistic. Nissan, Mars, etc. would never have moved to Williamson County if it weren't for all the amneties that are currently in Davidson County..."

So we should be proud of the part of "sucker" we played in their getting the high rollers?

When is is it our turn to be the money makers and our neighbors play the suckers?

Are you proud that we are supposedly paying for the items that makes people in Williamson prosperous?

Has it even crossed anyone's mind that we should stop and let our neighbors start "investing" in hotel/motel projects?

Why are you not concerned that our tax rate in the the urban services zone is twice that of the combined Franklin/Williamson/FSSD tax rate because we buy things they figure they do not have to buy?

We have got to examine the business plan underwear gnomes. There are steps missing between Step 1, Spend billions on tourists traps and Step 2, Profit.

I think I see the benefits of better schools. Good schools teach future citizens to not spend money when you can sucker the people in the next county into doing it. Bad schools teach people that convention centers will create 30,000 new jobs and the path to success involves working as a part time banquet server and party planner.

By: MusicCity615 on 5/7/12 at 5:01

JeffF,

quit acting like our schools were outstanding before Karl Dean was in office. The public school systems of any major city are always problematic, and the root of the problem can be traced back to the creation of the system itself. If you look at the allocation of Metro's General Fund, you will see that the majority of it goes to our schools. At some point, the FAMILIES have to take responsibility in educating their children and not just thinking more money will translate to better results. Washington DC will prove that, as more $ per student is spent there on education, but they have one of the nation's worst education systems.

I hate that Nissan is located in Williamson County, but there are many, many more things I like that Nashville has over brentwood/franklin. Bridgestone, HCA, Gaylord, Asurion, Emdeon, are just a few companies that you always fail to mention being in Davidson County.

By: Ask01 on 5/7/12 at 9:34

While it may be true that no property tax money has gone into the MCC YET, even my ex councilmember, whom I like to believe I had a hand in tossing out of office, admitted once, if the MCC did not generate enough revenue to cover the mortgage, upkeep, and all associated expenses, the onus would fall on the taxpayer, which would draw from the general fund and if the general fund was depleted, well, guess what? Property taxes WOULD have to be used.

So, yes, so far no property taxes have been used, we all know that. But it is early and the fact was also admitted during one highly charged council meeting failure to generate enough revenue could eventually come down to those monies being involved, so Mayor Dean's advocates should not try to employ the 'taxes not used' smoke screen.

All the rosy predictions are for businesses to make money. That is why all the business people support the facility. They see a way to pad their own bank accounts. (Businesses which provide catering, security, lighting, audio support, as well as those who promote and produce entertainment events certainly support this corporate welfare.)

I suppose the city will receive a cut of those profits through a trickle down process of taxes. I do wonder how far those monies will go toward covering all expenses so as not to be a burden on all taxpayers, not just property owners.

I notice Mayor Dean didn't really talk about the tax breaks granted to businesses. I know, I know the song and dance, "they create jobs," but so far, I have not seen any evidence this has happened, which is why I oppose corporate and business welfare.

Once they actually create some employment, real, full time, permanent positions with benefits paying decent wages, we can talk about some tax breaks, but show me some real jobs first. (I can't speak for anyone else, but I don't even acknowledge part ime, temporary, seasonal, minimum wage jobs as providing real employment.

I also noticed Mayor Dean sidestepped the question about putting the increase just below the threshhold to trigger a referendum. Lame, Mayor Dean, very very lame.

I stand by my original idea to lay off most of the high level, overpaid Metro government leadership, or reduce their pay and benefits so they might share the pain of those at the bottom. Starting with Mayor Dean and that Riebeling fellow.

I do recall among the benefits insinuated about the stadium was one that the investment would provide all manner of fabulous tax revenue for the city. I can't say I have seen anything tangible yet.

It is funny, though, that both former Mayor Bredesen and current, (wish he was former already) Mayor Dean both finagled deals with big promises then followed up with property tax increases.

All the silliness from Mayor Dean's supporters is, well, silliness. Deep down in their hearts, they know this is going to benefit only a small segment of Nashville's population.

It would be nice if they would just drop all pretense of concern for the city and admit they are in line to benefit.

By: MusicCity615 on 5/8/12 at 8:43

I am in no line to benefit and I support nearly everything Karl Dean has done in his administration. I think he has been an excellent mayor.

By: Ask01 on 5/13/12 at 8:13

Comments from Mayor Dean's supporters claiming to have no stake or opportunity to benefit from hizzoners grandiose schemes fall mostly on deaf ears, often ringing as hollow as the mayor's claims to have no plans for the Speedway and Fairgrounds, yet desperately seeking to raze the site.

I still cannot comprehend anyone supporting a person so capable of the apparent deceit we see.

Let's see, what are some of the achievements which inspire such pride in the mayor's supporters?

1. Not allowing citizens a vote on constructing the new convention center.

2. Committing tax money to build a new convention center, and basically giving away tax dollars under the guise of 'incentives' claiming the businesses will create jobs of unknown quality, then, after all this fluff, turning his attention to basic necessities of civic government, claiming economic misfortune.

3. Proposing a property tax set just below the threshhold to allow voters a say. Legal, perhaps, but certainly dishonorable in my view.

4. Even as the city, county, state, and nation begin a questionable, shaky recovery from a damaging recession, after proposing a sneaky tax increase, threatening to cut schools, police and other hot button issues because, one supposes we are broke, Mayor Dean wants to spend money we presumably don't have celebrate 50 years of Metropolitan government. (I prefer to think of this as Metropolitan tyranny.)

Quite an impressive list of skullduggery, wouldn't you say?

By: 551 on 6/8/12 at 8:57

http://www.monsoondressessale.com/

Monsoon Dressesaccessories company founded in 1973.We all know Monsoon not only gives rain which allow crops to grow,but also makes us charming with Monsoon Clothing.Our store are variety of Monsoon UKdresses available for you to choose from.Monsoon Saledresses has developed a distinctive style and is known for carrying bright, colorful items that seem to be ethnic in origin. If you want a real Monsoon Maxi Dresses,you'll have to buy it fromMonsoon Dresses onlinein the United Kingdom.As everyone who's ever bought Monsoon Bridal Dressesknows, the monsoon is a famous world brand, quality is guaranteed. However,You can easily be all sizes in our Monsoon Store as a monsoon fashion fan,NowMonsoon Bridesmaid Dresses,Monsoon Party Dresses,Monsoon Day Dresses,Monsoon Knitted Dresses and Monsoon Evening Dresseson sale. Free, fast shipping. Feel great quality buy now!

By: 551 on 6/8/12 at 8:57

http://www.clarksukshoes.com/

Since their humble beginning back in 1825 Clarks shoes has built upon their reputation for quality by continuously revolutionizing the comfort footwear industry.From their inception,the Clarks brand has been synonymous with comfort,quality and style.Utilizing a wide range of high quality leathers and a surprisingly fresh approach to shoe design,Clarks continues to offer a broad range of fashionable shoe styles for both clarks mens shoes and clarks women shoes.Whether your looking for a casual leather flip flop,a unique slide,or comfortable casual dress shoe Clarks is sure to have the right style for you.
As always,Clarks uk shoes continues to use only the finest leather,suede and nubuck in each and every shoe.Recently,the introduction of the unstructured series has offered consumers a number of innovative and exciting styles that utilize the Clarks Sandals exclusive Air Circulation Systemâ„¢.The ACS system controls the interior climate of the shoe by allowing warm air to dissipate while cool air is pulled in.Additionally,Clarks sale Unstructured clarkes shoes are thoughtfully designed to be softly cushioned and have an exceptionally lightweight flexible construction that clarks boots allows you to move about more freely and naturally.
By purchasing a pair of Clarks originals shoes you will be joining a tradition of quality,comfort and style that has stood the test of time.

By: 551 on 6/9/12 at 12:55

Few watch aficionados realize that the Japanese brand seiko watch has a history as old as many of its Swiss rivals. Founded in the 1880s, the company began manufacturing wrist seiko watches after World War I and quickly became an innovative leader, developing one of the world's first seiko automatic and seiko chronograph. But perhaps Seiko's greatest achievement came about in its race with the American brand Bulova to harness new technology, leading to the quartz watch, which revolutionized the industry and nearly drove the Swiss out of business.
More innovations followed, including the first computer wristwatch, in 1984, and the first nonbattery seiko kinetic watch. To this list we can now add another groundbreaker: the Seiko Spring Drive mechanical movement, which is accurate to one second per day, making it approximately three times more precise than the average mechanical watch. The Spring Drive also provides an enduring seventy-two hours of power reserve (most watches offer about forty) and winds 30 percent faster than a conventional movement.
According to seiko uk, twenty-eight years of work went into developing this movement, and only five of the company's hundreds of watchmakers possess the requisite skills to assemble it. Regardless of its technological history, the seiko 5 is a skillfully designed watch, with graceful hands and interesting use of off-center dials.

By: 551 on 6/9/12 at 3:08

In recent years, the golf ball movement grew in popularity, is no longer high society or the family special sports. Golf is more younger, also become popular leisure sports.Seiko watch launch designed for holiday leisure sports design waves table, using Seiko patent technology white titanium metal case with an exclusive development surface hardening process, make metal colour and lustre and lightsome texture. seiko watches have wear resistance, even long wear also can maintain the original luster.
See a man ever taste, don't see his appearance, not watching his height and his wallet,also don't see his degree, as long as see what he wear, necks, surrounded on the waistband's three points feeling. And the most point is what the price of the Wrist Wearseiko uk Watches.
Want to know the man what wear, except beyond the simple wedding ring, the only decorations are seiko kinetic watch . The most vexed is man took gold jewelry, and as long as Cultured person in the neck wear a boss type yellow thick neck chain, on your finger sparkling glistening gold ring. That will discount yourself of that image, became a vulgar people. But exception a watch, the golden yellow watch no matter how to say that all of the same style than gold bracelet have grade. Visible, Seiko watches for men this thing in a man really have decayed for magical attunements of magic power. So, when a boudoir friend to ask me what gift give their most dear man, I'll be solemnly use "watch" two sonorous powerful words to express my opinion.
I really can't remember what better thanseiko 5 watches more suitable for a man and women, he will not let his woman waiting, punctual man must need a good watches,and no man will take an alarm clock to slip away to reach everywhere. Urge oneself of man fast growth for a good man, sent him watch is better. Of course, you still can chooseladies seiko watches ,seiko kinetic Watches,seiko watches uk , chronograph Seiko watches, seiko automatic watches and so on.

By: 551 on 6/9/12 at 3:18

Monsoon dresses are a great tool in any woman's fashion arsenal. They are stylish and affordable. The brand started in the 1970's and began by only making coats. Since then they have branched out into all types of different fashion arenas including mens, womens and childrens.
There are many different styles of Monsoon clothing to choose from,such as Monsoon Maxi Dresses ,Monsoon Bridal Dresses ,Monsoon Party Dresses ,Monsoon Bridesmaid Dresses and Monsoon Knitted Dresses .They offer some options that are form fitting, some that are more of a loose fit, and some for the plus size woman. The dresses come in a variety of styles and colors. They are expertly crafted and will make any woman look amazing.
There are many occasions that Monsoon uk dresses would be extremely appropriate. Because they offer such a vast variety they can be worn to many different types of events. They can be worn to a monsoon wedding or a cocktail party or even just a fun social gathering.
The internet is one of the best places to find Monsoon dress . A simple search on your favorite search engine will point you in the right direction. Most major department stores carry the dresses as well. It is really up to you which way you choose. Either way, you will be happy you bought a Monsoon sale dress!

By: 551 on 6/9/12 at 9:30

[url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/]Seiko watches[/url] have a very rich heritage dating way back to the nineteenth century that was and still is dedicated to perfection. Environmental issues nowadays are a big factor that drives consumer buying habits. This [url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/]Seiko Watch[/url] has been blazing the trail when it comes to combining environmental conservation and watch making.

[url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/]Seiko UK[/url] are produced in plants that have fully complied with the waste disposal management regulations. This has gone down to the process of production to intricate steps of soldering where the quantities of lead have been reduced. This [url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/specials.html]Seiko Watches UK[/url] has many firsts including being the only one to fit mercury free batteries.

Currently research is underway to develop alternative sources of power to cut down on the impact of used and discarded batteries. In addition to this, [url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/seiko-solar-watches-c-81.html]Seiko Solar[/url] powered units are being tested in a bid to completely eliminate the use of batteries in the watches. Such a display of an aggressive desire to go green has not been witnessed for a very long time.

To further underscore the uniqueness of these products, only a small number of technicians are involved during the actual production of these watches. Production is shared between two studios and two hundred and forty craftsmen. [url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/]Seiko[/url] has been a pioneer in watch production, the first divers piece was commissioned by this company in the early sixties. It could resist the water pressure up to a depth of one hundred and fifty metres.
The Seiko Sale has the collection of [url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/seiko-ladies-watches-c-74.html]Ladies Seiko Watches[/url],[url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/seiko-kinetic-watches-c-75.html]Seiko Kinetic[/url],[url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/products_new.html]Seiko Monster[/url],[url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/]Seiko Automatic[/url],[url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/]Seiko 5[/url],[url=http://www.ladiesseikowatches.com/seiko-mens-watches-c-73.html]Seiko Mens Watches[/url],you are warm welcome to buy one from them.

By: 551 on 6/10/12 at 8:54

Michael Kors are the first designer of lady's wear of mass production.He has based his own michael kors brand in 1981 year.One more collection of michael kors outletbags of a fall-winter season 2011-2012 is accessories in ethno-style with elements of different cultures.There are many fashionable Michael Kors Shoulder Tote from our site.High soft michael kors bag perfectly quality into a better and even charming style. The new michael kors bag is a gorgeous to wear for you in 2012.while we increases the superior product, that include Michael Kors Watches, michael kors tote and michael kors purse.Look at our site which you will really absolutely love these michael kors bags. You can also find quite a few in vogue michael kors wallet involving affordable prices.If you are looking for michael kors handbags information try our michael kors sale product page.

By: 886 on 6/13/12 at 10:03

The fired season,the fired Coast Dress

As we know,summer is coming,it's a hot season.

It's the best time to show your beauty.

Coast Dresses is the choice for you. It's a special brand of the best dress designed for
all kinds of woman.You will fall in love with the dress about Coast UK once you wear it.
Your heart will tell you that it love the Coast Dresses and call you to purchase it  quickly.The Coast Dresses is beautiful,fashion,graceful,kingly,and fancy,

There are day dresses,work dresses,wedding dresses and others.

Welcome to coast sale uk shop,you will show your beauty and temperament once you wear the Coast Dresses.