Metro school board becomes arena for political class, biz execs

Sunday, July 15, 2012 at 10:05pm

Nashville’s political class — and some education-minded out-of-state business executives — has found a new arena in which to play: Metro public schools and the board that governs it.

Sure, doling out money to individuals hoping to snag a seat on the nine-member Metro school board is nothing unusual. But Nashville hasn’t seen anything quite like this. It appears the school board candidate — in a city grappling with charter school growth, privatization and continued chamber-of-commerce influence — is suddenly equal to state lawmaker and Metro Council member as cash targets. 

When financial disclosures trickled in to the Davidson County Election Commission last week — the deadline to submit second-quarter campaign finance reports had arrived — District 9 candidate Margaret Dolan and District 5 contender Elissa Kim shattered previous fundraising records for school board races in Nashville.

Dolan, vice president of community relations at Ingram Industries and a candidate seeking the West Nashville seat that Kay Simmons is exiting, boasted a campaign war chest of $106,404. Kim, a Teach for America executive challenging board chairwoman Gracie Porter, hauled in $81,414.

Both smashed school board fundraising marks of Simmons, former board member Alan Coverstone and ex-board chair David Fox, whose $63,065 fundraising total in 2006 was the previous high. In fact, the Dolan-Kim duo accounted for nearly half of the $377,703 raised by all 17 candidates vying for five school board seats.

District 7 candidate Will Pinkston’s campaign tally of $52,749 — which would have led the way in previous election cycles — seemed somewhat pedestrian in comparison. Coming in fourth was District 3 candidate Jarod DeLozier, who raised $35,555. Early voting for Metro’s school board races began Friday. Election day is Aug. 2.

Outside money has played a role in the fundraising jolt, specifically for Kim, who collected 30 percent of her dollars from individuals who don’t live in Tennessee, including a handful employed at high-profile private equity firms. Maxing out with a $1,400 contribution to Kim were people like Stephen Mandel, a billionaire hedge fund manager from Greenwich, Conn.

“They’re education philanthropists,” Kim said of her outside donors, including Mandel who she’s known for years through the Teach For America network. Many are longtime friends, she said. Others previously worked for her.

Yet donors from Nashville’s most affluent zip codes also left marks on fundraising efforts.

“For a number of years, people could not see a vision for how public education could be reformed,” said Lee Barfield, an attorney at Bass, Berry & Sims, who donated to Dolan, Kim and Pinkston, along with chipping in $1,000 to a pro-charter school PAC dubbed Great Public Schools.

Attitudes have rapidly changed, he said, citing various education trends at the state level. Barfield also referred to Nashville’s boom in publicly financed, privately run charter schools. He said Metro’s central office has historically served as a “monopoly,” but the charter movement is quickly upending that perception. Dollars to pro-charter candidates have followed. 

“If you feel like that public education is a hole, and there’s no way out of it, then you’re unlikely to give money,” Barfield said. “On the other hand, if you see that there is a vision, a way public education can be improved — and a part of that is to have quality people on the school board — then people are more willing to step up to the plate.”

Dolan, who serves on a number of nonprofit boards in Nashville and enjoys Mayor Karl Dean’s support, said she drew heavily from her community involvement. Her donors include several Nashvillians with private school connections along with high-profile names: Martha, John and Orrin Ingram of Ingram Industries; businessman Michael Shmerling and Nashville Convention Center Authority chairman Marty Dickens, among a long list of others. 

“If I look at my list of contributors, these are mainly individuals that I’ve worked with over a long period of time — many, many years — on various community endeavors, a lot of it around public education,” Dolan said.  

But Dolan and Kim also benefited financially from the backing of the Nashville Area Chamber of Commerce and a budding charter school crowd.

Each collected $7,100 checks from the Nashville Area Chamber of Commerce’s SuccessPac, an equal amount from the pro-charter school PAC Great Public Schools, and $3,000 contributions from a PAC formed by StudentsFirst, a new education organization that former Washington, D.C., schools chancellor Michelle Rhee leads. The group, which supports charters and is wary of teachers unions, also gave money to Pinkston.

“Absolutely not,” Dolan said when asked whether her special-interest money could force her votes if elected to the school board. “As a matter of fact, I’ve made that clear to every group that invited me to speak with them.”

Amy Frogge finished a distant second in fundraising among District 9 candidates, raking in $17,864. The only District 9 candidate with Metro schoolchildren, Frogge said her figure is “sufficient” to run an effective campaign. But she added: “It’s a shame we’re spending so much money on these campaigns when it could be better used in our schools.

“People are tired of the nonsense in our schools,” she said, recounting conversations with West Nashville voters. “They’re tired of the bickering. They’re tired of the special interests. And they’re tired of politics intruding on our public schools. Public school parents are tired of hearing that the schools are broken.” 

Several names appear on both Dolan and Kim’s contributor lists, people such as Steve Turner, principal of MarketStreet Enterprises who heads the Turner Family Foundation, as well as other Turner family members. Steve Turner maxed out with contributions of $1,400 to both candidates while also giving $2,500 to the pro-charter PAC.

Dolan and Kim also collected checks from Natasha Kamrani, president of the Nashville Public Education Foundation. Kamrani is the wife of Chris Barbic, superintendent of the state’s Achievement School District, which presides over Tennessee’s lowest-performing schools. The ASD’s primary strategy is handing the reins of troubled schools to charter organizations. 

Kim, vice president for recruitment of Teach for America, a national group that turns college graduates into teachers, picked up 19 separate financial contributions from individuals who identified TFA as their employer, including CEO and founder Wendy Kopp. (The school board voted to renew Metro’s contract with TFA in February, electing to substantially increase its annual intake of TFA teachers to a range of 80 to 100.) In addition, Kim received money from several educators connected to KIPP Nashville, a charter organization that operates in District 5.

Kim, whose yard signs are plastered all over East Nashville’s trendy Five Points district, attributed her astounding fundraising haul to “hard work,” a robust online fundraising operation and “an enthusiastic base of people who are very receptive to the message.” Some local contributors are friends, she said, while others she met after her initial campaign announcement in April. She downplayed her PAC contributions, pointing out her 277 overall donors.

“To me, all of the PAC discussion is sort of distracting, because it’s such a small fraction of the total giving,” Kim said. She acknowledged there are competing interest groups, but said they “are all centered on kids.”

With her $81,414 fundraising mark, Kim outpaced Porter, the board chair, in the District 5 race by margin of more than 4 to 1. Porter, who has become the target of both charter supporters and the Service Employees International Union, reported raising $18,324; candidate John Haubenreich, $9,365; and Erica Lanier, $2,000. Kim has raised more money from out of state — $24,350 from 40 donors — than Porter has in all.

“Dollars do not vote; people vote,” Porter said. “It’s a connection to the community, and this is what I’m all about. I’m connected to the people of District 5 and the city of Nashville.” Asked whether outside groups contributing to school board candidates might expect something in return, Porter said, “I wouldn’t want to speculate on that.”

In recent election cycles, the chamber of commerce’s SuccessPAC has delivered similar monetary plays in school board races.

New on the scene this year, however, is Great Public Schools, the pro-charter PAC, which raised $34,300, and maxed out contributions to District 3’s DeLozier along with Kim and Dolan. Spearheading the group is a trio of affluent charter school backers: investor Bill DeLoache, a trustee of the Joe C. Davis Foundation who chairs the board of the Tennessee Charter Incubator; John Eason, a board member of the Tennessee Charter Schools Association; and Townes Duncan, managing partners of Solidus Company.

Bankrolling Great Public Schools is an assortment of business heavyweights: Auto dealership mogul Lee Beaman contributed $2,000 to the PAC; Jim Flautt, senior vice president of Asurion, delivered $2,500; Howard McClure, CEO of Change Healthcare, donated $3,000; and William Wilson, president of Cherokee Equity Group, contributed $3,000.

“The status quo is a pretty powerful thing,” said Flautt, a KIPP Academy board member who in addition to donating to Great Public Schools, contributed to Kim and DeLozier. “A lot of times you need bold leaders to make changes.”

Also among Great Public Schools’ contributors is Fox, the former Green Hills board member whose campaign in 2006 was Nashville’s first board race to usher in big dollars. Fox also donated to Dolan, Pinkston and Kim — the opponent of his former board colleague Porter.

“It’s long overdue that this amount of attention and resources is going into the composition of our school board,” Fox said. “For too long, the school board was seen as sort of a thankless and not terribly important job. Now I believe the community more widely understands that these are critical positions that have everything to do with the quality of classroom instruction.”

(Full disclosure: Townes Duncan heads the board of SouthComm, parent company of The City Paper. Neither Duncan nor anyone outside of The City Paper newsroom has input or access to stories before publication.)

13 Comments on this post:

By: Trumpet on 7/16/12 at 12:21

Joe/The Collection:

My quotable comment on this is..."No Comment."

Certainly, a 21st Century "can of worms."

Jody...from Salemtown....Pearl High School-Class of 1961

By: Leazee on 7/16/12 at 1:21

The charters have not performed as well as most people subscribe. I gather, however, that this is the direction that the business sector choses to go. They started by getting Alan Coverstone in place. Obviously, having let the schools get to the point that 70% of our public students live below the poverty line and the schools are viewed as not fixable, this sector wants no other choice. I remain uncomfortable that the chosen candidates of Dean, the Chamber and the business sector are being money whipped and are sure to grace every charter application. Many of the money people are the same group that gathered to defeat the anti-discrimination bill put before the city council because they are homophobic. Dickens, Beamon, etc. met in the dark at the Lifeway Building. to plan strategy. and they were successful. The Great Hearts Academies of Phoenix are appealing their application for a third time. They know that they will be approved by these candidates if they win. This is the charter designed to instruct children in the 37205,37215 zips and will be segregated. The public schools will receive little or no support from the money groups now or ever. Easy for them. Most of their children have all attended $25,000 private schools. There are ways to fix the schools but unless you are a part of the public system, you have no clue. Ultimately, this will not serve Nashville well.

By: Ask01 on 7/16/12 at 4:08

"Metro school board becomes arena for political class, biz execs"

Too bad it can't be about educating children, don't you think?

By: westisbest on 7/16/12 at 6:30

I just don't get the argument about segregation and charter schools. Has anyone actually been in a charter school in Davidson Co that was diverse? What? And no wonder they are failing- until recent changes, a kid couldn't go to a charter school unless they were underpriviledged and failing.
I am happy to see that there is interest in the school board. Its Davidson Co schools are pathetic. My property taxes just went up dramatically yet I can't even send my kids to the public school in my own neighborhood. Most of the middle class families are forced to flee south of the border and seek refuge in Williamson Co so that their kids can get a decent education. Davidson Co is losing a HUGE tax base that way. Until the school system makes dramatic changes, this will continue to be the case. And I don't want to hear the argument of segregation. Seriously. It has been overplayed at this point. The only truly "diverse" schools are the ones near Nolensville road and Charlotte Pike where the neighborhoods are truly diverse.

By: pswindle on 7/16/12 at 10:41

Don't vote for any School Board candidate that is endorsed by the Chamber.

By: Nashvegan on 7/16/12 at 12:11

I'm confused....if rich people don't care about public schools because they send their kids to private school, why is their wanting to be involved (or maybe supporting candidates who support charter schools) a bad thing? Maybe they actually want to make the public schools better so their kids can experience more diversity or give other parents the option to get a good education without having to go to private school. BTW, I am a product of MNPS, start to finish save for one year (1st grade).

By: murdog on 7/16/12 at 12:24

Amy Frogge is by far the superior candidate and this city should be grateful to have someone of her caliber and character in the race and on the school board. You will find very few people with her level of commitment or dedication. Amy's children attend Metro schools so I implore all of you, please do the right thing, vote for Amy Frogge and put Davidson county's children and students first and show the elites that big money will not always win in the end.

By: morpheus120 on 7/16/12 at 1:06

None of this should surprise anyone after Tennessee won the Race to the Top award.

Millions of fed dollars are pouring into the state and that means all the charters and their supporters are lining up like pigs to the trough. You won't see all the fuss like this in the rural areas, btw, because there aren't enough students for it to be profitable. Nashville and Memphis are now ground zero for the privatizers.

This is about PROFIT, not education. Why else would rich parents who can afford to send their kids to private schools give a damn about public schools? Because many of them stand to gain financially from it. Which I guess wouldn't be so bad if there was ANY compelling evidence that charters are outperforming public schools when they are on an equal footing. But there isn't. We are simply taking money away from public schools and handing it over to the businessmen. No accountability, no wage and benefit standards, and not being held to the same criteria as public schools are.

The sad thing is that there are PROGRESSIVES who should know better who are falling for the "school choice" scam. If you are a liberal, you are being hoodwinked by people with a profit motive and who want to bust unions. Stop drinking the Kool-Aid and open your eyes!

By: govskeptic on 7/17/12 at 9:22

Should membership on the School Board be limited to those that have been
selected, coached and endorsed by only the Teachers Union, SEIU and
those benefiting from connection to the Education system? If so, that may
be a big contributor to 30 yrs of decline!

By: pswindle on 7/17/12 at 11:38

Why can we not elect people from Nashville, that knows Nashville? It is the outside people that are coming in and telling Nashville what to do. If we allow the Charter Schools to dominate Metro Nashville's school system, we will lose the importance of what the public schools do for our childrfen and the community. The public must understand that all of the teachers in Charter Schools do nos have degrees. As long as one or two so called leaders have degrees they think that is enough. Metro-Nashville would never hire without degrees.

By: Bellecat on 7/18/12 at 7:49

This is only about business people making money. They see dollar signs in that great big world of education. This is a travesty for our electoral process, our public school system, and our country as a whole. Money should never be the pivotal factor in who is elected to any position from school board to POTUS. Having money come from outside the district, much less from outside the state, and probably even from outside the country is alarming and insane.

This is definitely a movement to take our public education system away from the citizens and children, and give it to Big Business to fullfill their never ending greed for more money. Public education is not without problems, but they can be fixed, and it has served us well in the past. Look at the generations of presidents, physicians, scientists,writers, humanitarians, Pulitizer and Nobel prize winners, on and on, that the public school system has given us.

When the end goal is money and profit, the product will suffer. Educating our children should not be about investors making a killing in profits.

By: Fernanda on 7/21/12 at 2:05

Truth be told there might be a trustworthy great variety of band t-shirts on your often the market today. While a number of them designs include an absolute picture of which the entire band, others only currently have a huge small logo. High school students and also college students perhaps may be especially keen for wearing common t-shirts, thus many schools come with made rules polo ralph lauren shirts in cheap polo ralph lauren the region of the actions types of t-shirts are perhaps appropriate to wear at school. Band t-shirts are almost always commonly found inside the most important restricted list.
 The entire for the most part popular t-shirts among specific teenagers could be those of punk and so rock band logos and photos. Quite a number of t-shirts come having 1 interesting logo plus scene through our own front of cheap ralph lauren shirts our own t-shirt making the company a complete desirable item. If you are attending a show your family may very well realize that particular often which the cheapest souvenir everyone may bring is simply virtually any band t-shirt. Apart from buying every one of them at shows and also concerts, you will ought to create themselves using which the internet. Cyber space is going to be a person's prime place to shop for t-shirts featuring favorite bands in addition to performers.
 Currently the best band t-shirt happens to be undoubtedly one who has a brand new great design, fits well also is considered to be cheap. In that respect there would be many t-shirt discount ralph lauren collectors as a consequence finding both of them cheap is almost certainly quite any issue for cheap ralph lauren polo themselves. EBay offers many great deals so as discount polo ralph lauren far in the role of t-shirts would be concerned. An individual will certainly in fact find such which is normally unable to locate anywhere other than there. The following can be much better to search online for t-shirts or entertainment merchandise when compared with what visit many random shops.
 The activities is probably really great about band t-shirts will be in which it they can come in many different fits, we has the ability to find girl fit tee which hugs the actual waist and ralph lauren polo flares out at a bottom. Extended sizes of band cheap ralph lauren clothes t-shirts would be in addition ralph lauren shirts available. Until this is very much great news for a lot of heavy men and so women that prefer to currently have their very own band t-shirts consisting of another little extra room. Another factor worth considering is usually sleeve length. Generally there cheap ralph lauren actually are many t-shirts by means of three-quarter sleeves while others get no sleeves at every one of the. Of course, people can easily as well contain any traditional short sleeved t-shirt.
 Usually best of the exact band t-shirts are almost always quite inexpensive because these guys have got an actual promotional purpose. After the majority of, anyone using your own band t-shirt promotes an individuals product for free every time wearing that it. This is what is almost certainly a very good advertisement for those bands which are generally actually really popular and for seem to be brand novel. How they are after to locate your current world learn in the region of this music along with now there should be genuinely a definite better way together with giving away band t-shirts. Thought is in fact however true any established bands along the lines of those Rolling Stones charge more for this special band t-shirts whilst all the people probably are good icon also don need to gain upcoming fans. ralph lauren polo shirts

By: Fernanda on 7/21/12 at 2:10

Ones winter collection in men wear always brings forth replacement exciting designs. Leading brands bring out a ralph lauren polo shirts new range of formal as well as informal dress items. Calvin Klein, Ralph Lauren, Giorgio Cosani, Demantie, Haspel, Jack Victor and so Kenneth Cole were a little of the actual leading labels in men fashion. Customers may easily view one particular latest collection in exclusive showrooms as well as supermarkets or to visit online shopping websites.
 Customers may easily search for clothes in specific categories. In one particular formal wear section, that there will definitely be regular formal suits such when tuxedos and also business suits. Formal suits unquestionably are available in single-breasted like cheap ralph lauren well as double-breasted. One would polo ralph lauren cheap look for dresses for special occasions such compared to wedding suits. Another number of ralph lauren shirts cheap novel designs happen to be available in the wedding collection. Suits should be available in different shades and so cheap ralph lauren polo textures. This particular season, people may want to look for woolen suits too. A nice range of stylish blazers generally what's more available in the particular market. Calvin Klein is often offering the best formal blazer with vest. discount polo ralph lauren One may easily furthermore , find specific dress items for example discount ralph lauren like trousers and so shirts. Trousers are already available in a new range of fabrics such as a cheap ralph lauren clothing cotton, fine wool in addition to worsted wool. In ralph lauren polo those shirts?segment, linen shirts perhaps may be available in elegant prints also shades. Luchiano Visconti is also offering cotton along with linen shirts.
 In a men informal collection, a lot of could be particular special men suits products such as men cheap ralph lauren polos sport coats. A majority of these informal sports coats were available in cashmere, linen cheap ralph lauren polo shirts and camel hair ralph lauren cheap cloth. Through shopping websites, customers can potentially view a very whole range of men wear items as well as purchase products at special cheap ralph lauren shirts discounted prices.