Commentary: Why national media glossed over flooding

Tuesday, May 4, 2010 at 10:45pm
Patten Fuqua

If you live outside of Nashville, you may not be aware, but our city was hit by a 500-year-flood over the last few days. The national news coverage gave us 15 minutes, but went back to focusing on a failed car bomb and an oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. While both are clearly important stories, was that any reason to ignore our story? It may not be as terror-sexy as a failed car bomb or as eco-sexy as an oil spill, but that’s no reason to be ignored.

The Cumberland River crested at its highest level in over 80 years. Nashville had its highest rainfall totals since records began. People drowned. Billions of dollars in damage occurred. It is the single largest disaster to hit Middle Tennessee since the Civil War. And yet… no one knows about it.

Does it really matter? Eventually, it will… as I mentioned, there are billions of dollars in damage. It seems bizarre that no one seems to be aware that we just experienced what is quite possibly the costliest non-hurricane disaster in American history. The funds to rebuild will have to come from somewhere, which is why people need to know. It’s hard to believe that we will receive much relief if there isn’t a perception that we need it.

But let’s look at the other side of the coin for a moment. A large part of the reason that we are being ignored is because of who we are. Think about that for just a second. Did you hear about looting? Did you hear about crime sprees? No, you didn’t. You heard about people pulling their neighbors off of rooftops. You saw a group of people trying to move two horses to higher ground. No, we didn’t loot. Our biggest warning was, “Don’t play in the floodwater.” When you think about it, that speaks a lot for our city. A large portion of why we were being ignored was that we weren’t doing anything to draw attention to ourselves. We were handling it on our own.

Some will be quick to find fault in the way rescue operations were handled, but the fact of the matter is that the catastrophe could not have been prevented and it is simply ignorant to suggest otherwise. It is a flood. It was caused by rain. You can try to find a face to stick this tragedy to, but you’ll be wrong.

Parts of Nashville that could never even conceivably be underwater were underwater. Some of them still are. Opry Mills and the Opryland Hotel are, for all intents and purposes, destroyed. People died sitting in standstill traffic on the Interstate. We saw boats going down West End Avenue. And, of course, we all saw the surreal image of the portable building from Lighthouse Christian floating into traffic and being destroyed when cars were knocked into it. I’m still having trouble comprehending all of it.

And yet…life will go on. We’ll go back to work, to school, to our lives, and we’ll carry on. In a little over a month, I’ll be on this website talking about the draft. In October, we’ll be discussing the new Predators’ season with nary a thought of these past few days. But in a way, they changed everyone in this town. We now know that that it can happen to us, but also know that we can handle it.

Because we are Nashville.

Patten Fuqua is a Nashville native and graduate of Belmont's journalism school. This commentary originally appeared on his Predators blog www.section303.com.

8 Comments on this post:

By: budlight on 5/5/10 at 7:34

Patten Fuqua you are a prince among men. And you are correct. We, as Tennesseans, pitch in and help. We sacrifice for others and love our fellow man/woman/child when the times get tough.

You get an A plus from this reader.

I thought it was just the politics. Now I see your side of the coin and I am willing to concede that you, not I, are correct. We didn't get media coverage because we remained civil under a horrendous amount of tragedy.

By: vechester on 5/5/10 at 9:59

Absolutely the best article I have read. All the Northeast media snobs missed it or glossed over this incredible weather event and tragedy.

Once we get through the recovery process, and we will, I would like to see the city place several permanent markers to designate this historic event and a plaque maybe a Riverfront Park that gives a summary of what this city endured in 2010. Just a thought...

By: ROTCMom on 5/5/10 at 10:35

ROTCMom
While I can't speak for the national media as a whole, at least from my perspective we did get some national attention. I base that on the number of facebook inquiries, emails, and phone calls I got from all around the country from friends and acquaintances checking to make sure we were okay.

That said, the spirit of neighbor helping neighbor, stranger helping stranger, brought joy to my heart. While being fairly new to Middle Tennessee (a 5 year resident), I have found the spirit of southern hospitality demonstrated here on a daily basis is a contagious thing. The best decision my husband and I ever made was to move here, and I have no doubt this town will come back stronger than ever after this challenge.

By: budlight on 5/5/10 at 3:06

ROTC mom, cudos to your postive attitude; you are correct. Hope all is well with your family. Mine did not get flooded.

By: concretemike on 5/5/10 at 4:43

It's not a story with today's media (you can't call them news people anymore Cronkite is dead) unless the poor, downtrodden, living off of the government teat residents who are too lazy or dumb to heed a mandatory evacuation order from the governor and then have to be rescued from everybody from the Coast Guard to the National Guard.

That's right I am calling out those residents of the Crescent City otherwise known as New Orleans. FEMA isn't needed here watch and see what a lot of teamwork and elbow grease will do for a city when a natural disaster strikes and the locals pitch in together to rebuild instead of raping, robbing and pilfering from their city!

NASHVILLE RULES!!!!!!!!!

By: localboy on 5/6/10 at 12:06

Actually it seemed we got about as much coverage as other regional or local weather cataclysms - it just feels different when it happens in your hometown.

By: dmason48 on 5/8/10 at 9:45

I want you to know that I live in Edmond, Oklahoma (Oklahoma City area) and have been shocked at the lack of news coverage re: the flood.
Relatives of mine moved to Murfreesboro 3 years ago. They mentioned "heavy rains" prior to the flooding and then gave me updates as the situation worsened. This should have been on the national news full-time as was the Oklahoma City bombing or 9-11.
I had to go online to see slideshow photos at your local TV websites, and once in a while they offered a live stream of their coverage.
Anderson Cooper of CNN did say in an interview with Kenny Chesney that CNN had been contacted by people asking why the flood was getting almost no attention. He admitted that the oil spill and the attempted car bombing in Times Square had dominated the news. I understand that he did then go to Nashville to do reports.
I would like to come to your area and volunteer, perhaps at an animal shelter.
There are many of us across the country who care about what has happened in Nashville and are shocked, and in my case FURIOUS, that the national news has almost ignored you.

By: EddieA on 5/9/10 at 7:17

My sister-in-law telephoned from the Philippines on Saturday. She had seen the national news. Her main concern - Is everyone safe? Her second concern - Is there anything we can do? She lives across the world and offered financal help. Amazing when you consider the average Filipino earns $20.00 American a week.

I received conflicting reports. We have flood insurance but was told to not move anything until the adjuster viewed the damage. My flood insurance adjuster spent an estimated 15 minutes examining the damage under or home from our three seperate floodings. He gave me a pamplet from FEMA and I had to sign a form that I had received it. He never asked the question - Did it get into your home? It did.

He told me he would send me a claim amount - after we received an estimate on the heating/air conditioning and duct work. We had 60 days to accept the offer or the insurance company, Travelers, may not pay the claim.

He did not lie to me but he did not volunteer any informastion - we can file a supplemental claim. He reluctatntly admitted that. It is outlined in the FEMA pamplet I had to sign for. The AllState adjuster freely offered that information to my neighboor. The AllState adjuster also freely offered to my neighbor that they would pay for mold treatment. My adjuster intially stated they would not pay for treatment. They do not like to use the word "mold". Apparently it is a very dirty word after Katrina. They will pay for "cleanup".

AllState paid the claim on our 2000 Jeep Cherokee in three days. It was flooded at the Wal-Mart parking lot on Saturday May 1, 2010. We decided to keep the car because it is worth repairing - 84,000 miles. The AllState adjuster freely volunteered our options.

On the other side of blame, I have been complaining with Metro Storm since last year about a FEMA reclassification of our area in Antioch. Our three bedroom brick home with a crawl space was re-classified as a two-story home with an unfinished basement in 2008. I contacted Senator Cooper. His office attempted to have the Army Corp of Engineers issue new flood elevation certificates in our area based on a map FEMA created in 2002. However, FEMA has never certified the map.