On politics: Frist, GOP may have last laugh in 2010

Monday, May 12, 2008 at 1:43am

Former Senate Majority leader Dr. Bill Frist is the topic of much discussion behind the scenes of Tennessee politics lately. With the 2010 governor’s race looming, Frist is mentioned repeatedly as the presumptive Republican Party nominee — and a tough out for Democrats — should he choose to run.

The notion draws scorn from many Democrats in the state, particularly more liberal elements of the party in Nashville. The thinking is that Frist is damaged goods from his days in the Senate, left un-electable from gaffes like his video diagnosis of Terri Schiavo and the blame resting partially with Frist for the GOP losing the Senate in 2006.

Yet, Democratic Party insiders actually charged with running candidates against Republicans in Tennessee said Frist is going to be much more of a problem to dispatch than rank-and-file Democrats realize.

Numbers are already floating around Nashville concerning a possible Frist bid. Democratic operatives say the talk from the other side is that Frist’s fundraising goal would be $15 million followed by another $10 million in his own personal wealth if needed.

Those figures appear to be coming in part from noted GOP strategist and campaign manager Chip Saltsman, former chair of the GOP in Tennessee. Saltsman, fresh off his lead role in the surprisingly strong GOP presidential primary candidacy of former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee, didn’t dispel the idea he was talking up a Frist bid in town when asked. Saltsman was neck-deep in preparing for Frist’s aborted presidential bid before going to run Huckabee’s campaign.

“I’ve made no secret of the fact that I think this is a good idea,” Saltsman said of a Frist gubernatorial bid. “Dr. Frist needs to make up his mind about what he wants to do.”

Should Frist actually bring $25 million to the table for the 2010 gubernatorial race, it would be an unprecedented amount for a campaign in Tennessee. Democratic operatives from several sectors of the party suggest Frist’s people may not only be trying to scare off the field with such talk — though that is one goal. Democratic campaign types said they fully expect Frist’s reach into Nashville to be a problem for the Democratic Party in 2010.

Typically one of the state’s blue county, Democratic strongholds, there is a school of thought that many wealthy Nashville Democrats would have a hard time saying “no” to Frist and his family — one of the city’s oldest, most powerful business families still involved at the helm of the HCA hospital company. The thought process is that there will be a number of high-end Democratic donors in the city that would end up giving to both sides should Frist get in the race.

Democratic Party insiders have other numbers that make them feel pretty good about a Frist bid. At least one potential Democratic gubernatorial candidate has done some polling, and early numbers suggest Frist’s negatives among Tennesseans may be as high as the high 30 percent range. That could be balanced by what Saltsman and other GOP operatives say is a very high name recognition in the state.

A Frist run at public office in Tennessee has Nashville Democrats laughing. Some of the people charged with winning campaigns on their behalf do not seem to get the joke.

Filed under: City Voices
Tagged:
By: Time for Truth on 12/31/69 at 6:00

Frist would certainly be a strong candidate on name recognition alone. But his Bush-hugging, video-diagnosing, cat-skewering, insider-trading past will rise up to haunt him. Saltsman is a savvy campaign strategist but the albatross of his past closeness to Don Sundquist could be an issue too, albeit a small one.Democrats have only one high profile candidate in the wings, Harold Jr. He could beat Frist, perhaps easily in the right political climate. A lot of that will depend on who wins the Presidency and whether or not that winner is a success in office.Another possibility is Jim Cooper, who unlike Frist (or Lincoln Davis) could be a great governor. Like Frist, he is somewhat bookish, but with more substance and integrity. Cooper has been a conservative on fiscal accountability and a moderate on other issues. Cooper worked to keep the sales tax deduction while Frist concentrated on eliminating the inheritance tax. He better represents those Tennesseans who don't belong to Country Clubs.Bredesen will likely leave office with enough popularity to help whoever the Democratic candidate is. The question will be how much help would he want to give.

By: MJB on 12/31/69 at 6:00

I agree, TfT, but Jim Cooper isn't an exciting campaigner. Of course, neither is Bill Frist. Harold Ford speaks better than either of them, but he would need a higher percentage to outweigh the racist vote. Ford must win by 55%, not the 51% that the other candidates need. In any case, the state doesn't progress much. Frist is viciously conservative. Cooper & Ford are, like, Bredesen, moderately conservative. Tennessee desperately needs--like Wisconsin a century ago--a progressive party.

By: bmazor on 12/31/69 at 6:00

Tennessee would have a progressive party, sometimes referred to as The Democratic Party, if it had more progressives.

By: MJB on 12/31/69 at 6:00

It has enough progressives, Mazor, but they are splintered (& don't have the cash). You are correct, though, that if we get an increasing influx of intelligent people from other parts of the country--New England & the upper midwest, principally--, then we can move Tennessee forward.

By: monitorman on 12/31/69 at 6:00

If Frist were to be elected, look for HCA to take over what is left of TennCare.

By: gwhillikers on 12/31/69 at 6:00

Frist is a lightweight. But then the guy who pulled the strings to get him the senate post was/is a lightweight as well!

By: Anna3 on 12/31/69 at 6:00

To quote James Carville..."You can't beat somebody with nobody". Who do the Dems have? Even Harold Ford Jr. is smart enough to avoid this clash. and...will the Dems pony up the cash for a lost cause? I think not. Frist is making the rounds doing Lincoln Day Dinners, campaigning for Legislative Candidates, and Womens Clubs in Tennessee...and the Dems...they are going to have to fight out who will be their standard bearer...(Between a rural Congressman and a Female Former Legislator from Clarksville) all while the cash and momentum move toward Frist. The Repubs are clearing the decks and Harwell, Blackburn, and Wamp will be standard bearers for Frist in their own heavily Republican districts..(Which means Frist's base is very safe!)...and Frist will be in Nashville, cutting the heart out of the Democratic money machine...twisting arms. Not even a "Pit Bull" Plantiffs Attorney is stupid enough to be seen on the donors lists of the Dem. candidate in this one...and...P.S. To all of you who want to trot out Schiavo and to dissect the cats again...all of this was used against Frist before...and he still prevailed...Do you really want to start a fight where Frist gets to say he was erring on the side of saving a life...and give him a chance to talk about all of the lives he's saved? Go ahead...make his day!